Choosing new HR technology can easily become overwhelming.
There are countless platforms to research, demos to schedule, and features to compare.
So where should you start?
For some organizations, having guidance from an HR technology consultant can help bring structure to the process. An experienced consultant can help your team understand what you actually need, narrow the field, and evaluate potential solutions based on the outcomes that matter most.
Brett Ungashick, Founder and CEO of HR technology consulting firm OutSail, has helped thousands of organizations navigate technology decisions. Drawing from that experience, he shared several considerations HR leaders should keep in mind when evaluating and choosing new HR technology.
Start with the Root Problem
Before you start your search, it’s important to understand what your team is trying to solve.
It can be tempting to hear your team say, “we need new technology,” and immediately start booking demos. But that statement may point to a deeper issue within your process.
For Ungashick, getting to the underlying problem is one of the first steps in determining whether a new technology is even the right answer. “The statement of ‘we need new technology’ is often a symptom, but not the root cause,” he explains. “That’s what we really want to get to right away, is what’s the true problem that we’re trying to solve? Once we know that, then we can move forward pretty confidently.”
Before evaluating vendors, take time to understand what is creating the problem. Ask questions like:
- Where is our current process breaking down?
- What is taking too much time or creating unnecessary work?
- Is the issue related to our technology, our processes, our team, or a combination?
- What would need to change for the problem to feel resolved?
You may discover that you do need new technology. You may also discover that the bigger issue is a process that needs to be redesigned or a team that needs additional resources.
Either way, you’ll have a much stronger foundation for making a technology decision.
Anchor Your Evaluation With Key Outcomes
Once you understand the problem, think about what you need the solution to accomplish.
Maybe your team needs to reduce manual work. Maybe information needs to be easier to access. Maybe employees need a simpler experience. Or perhaps your organization has grown and your current technology can no longer keep up.
Historically, many technology searches have started with a list of features: identify everything you want a platform to do, then ask vendors how many boxes they can check.
But according to Ungashick, that approach can make it harder to distinguish between vendors.
“It’s gotten very easy to build features very fast,” Ungashick notes. “If you just say, here’s our 600 features we need, and send it out to 10 vendors, you’re going to get 10 responses that have 599 check marks back.
Instead, he recommends starting with goals.
“If you go with goals, that’s where every vendor has to pick what they are going to be about. If you’re really clear what your goals are, you can start to do that matching and not with everyone looking the same.”
The distinction is important.
A feature tells you what a platform can do. An outcome tells you what you need the platform to change.
When evaluating vendors, keep your most important outcomes front and center. They’ll give you a better way to determine whether a solution is actually a fit.
Prioritize What Your Team Needs
Once you have identified your key outcomes, you still need to determine which ones should come first.
Ungashick describes this through Maslow’s hierarchy of needs. Some capabilities, such as AI and professional development tools, may sit toward the top of the hierarchy, while foundational challenges like payroll reliability, time and attendance, and other core processes are toward the bottom.
That means the right technology investment can look different depending on where your organization is today.
For example, if your team is spending significant time fixing payroll, solving those problems with the right technology can help free up time to focus on higher-level priorities like automating tasks with AI.
Regardless of where your team falls on that hierarchy, the goal is the same: find technology that helps with the things taking up the most time and energy today, so your team has more room to focus on what’s next.
3 Factors That Can Have an Outsized Influence On Your Decision
Even if you have clear goals, it’s important to know which factors can have an outsized influence on your decision. For Ungashick, there are three that every HR leader should know:
1. Look and Feel
A platform should be easy for your team to use, but don’t confuse a visually appealing interface with a good user experience.
Pay attention to how many steps it takes to complete common tasks, how easy information is to find, and whether the workflow feels intuitive for the people who will actually use it.
“How [a solution] looks is less important than [the user experience],” Ungashick explains. “How simple is it to get things done? How simple are processes? UI gets weighed more heavily because it’s easier to grade.”
A polished interface can make a strong first impression, but it doesn’t necessarily mean the platform will make your team’s work easier.
In practice: Give vendors real scenarios and ask them to show you how those tasks would work from start to finish.
Ungashick recommends, “give the vendor very specific scenarios, watch them play out, keep in mind how many clicks one took versus the other, etc. The UI piece gets overrated.”
2. The Salesperson
The sales process can tell you something about how a company operates, but it shouldn’t make the decision for you.
A disorganized or difficult sales process may be worth paying attention to. But a great salesperson also shouldn’t be enough to convince you to purchase a platform that doesn’t meet your needs.
Ungashick points out, “If a vendor shows up with a bad attitude, poor organization, that can be a reflection of what’s to come. I don’t think you discount it, but at the same time, you have to keep in mind that sales reps go away when you sign a contract and you can’t make that too big of an influence.”
In practice: consider what the sales process tells you while keeping your focus on whether the technology actually meets your organization’s needs.
3. Initial Pricing
Price will always matter when evaluating a new technology. But the first number a vendor presents doesn’t necessarily tell you everything you need to know. Ungashick says buyers can sometimes see a price that feels too high and immediately eliminate a solution they otherwise like.
In practice: if a platform is a strong fit, it can be worth having another conversation. What does the ROI look like? Will this solution improve your team’s retention rate? Does this tool improve team performance? There are many factors to consider when it comes to pricing, and the overall value your team receives may be worth the investment in a new tool.
Look Closely at What Happens After You Sign
One of the biggest areas HR teams can overlook during an evaluation is what happens once the sales process ends.
Implementation, training, ongoing support, and the people your team will work with can all shape whether a technology improves the ROI of your team.
Ungashick emphasizes the importance of looking closely at this part of the relationship before making a decision: “The thing that [HR teams are] not looking into enough [is the support]. What is implementation going to look like? What is our support going to look like? Who are we going to be working with? How are we going to get set up and trained and have continuous support? That portion of it ends up being one of the biggest deciding factors of success or failure with a new solution.”
The Right Technology Should Create a Smoother Experience
Choosing the right HR technology comes down to having a clear understanding of what your organization needs and maintaining that focus throughout the evaluation process. Start with the problem, define the outcomes that matter most, and look beyond the sales presentation to understand how the technology will actually work for your team.
For teams evaluating technology for leave management, the software you select should help create a smoother experience for HR, employees, and managers. Tilt’s Leave Experience Management platform gives HR teams the visibility and control they need while providing employees and managers with a clear, connected experience throughout the leave process. With the flexibility to manage leave in-house or with premium support from Tilt’s leave specialists, teams can choose the level of support that works best for their organization. To learn more, take a tour of our platform or meet with a member of our team.
About OutSail
OutSail is an HR technology advisory firm that helps organizations find the right software for their needs. With expert guidance and insight into the HR tech market, OutSail helps HR teams navigate the buying process with greater confidence and find solutions that support their goals.
Learn more about how OutSail helps HR teams navigate HR technology decisions.